Cisco-Linksys EtherFast Cable/DSL Router with 4-Port 10/100 Switch
|
|
Our Price: $78.99 Availability: Usually ships in 1-2 business days Buy Used: from $9.94 (click here) Category: CE See more product details |
|---|
Called tech support and they were nice, but after their scripted help procedures, essentially clueless, and passed us off to a promised escalation call sometime soon. Call came the next day, by which time we had run to the nearest Wal-Mart and gotten ourselves another one. So far so good. Got the RMA for the original router in a timely fashion and sent it back. (Still waiting for replacement at the time of this review, which we will stick in a closet, if it works, and hope we never need to use it.)
7 days later, the router (same model)that we purchased from Wal-Mart died, same symptoms. Did not bother calling tech support, but took this one back the next night and got a fresh one after work. Dead out of the box. Went to a different Wal-Mart after dinner, took the dead one back, and got another one. Again, dead out of the box.
Hooked up one computer directly to the cable modem and researched this router a bit more, and completely concur with all the negative reviews on this product, after our experiences. Next day, we bought a Netgear RP614 router, and after an initial call to tech support to work out an issue with the router talking to our kind of cable modem (a "telco" or 2 way modem, which needs a cable connection for the downstream, and a phone line dail-up connection to complete the upstream), we were up and running smoothly, and have had no more troubles with the network since then. Bonus on the Netgear RP614 too - it comes with its own ethernet cable, so you don't have to buy one!
It worked right out of the box on my 3 computers (1 Mac). I could not believe it. After sweating to get NetBEUI to run my internal network, I would never think that setting up a network could be this easy. As long as you have Networking and TCP/IP enabled (you have to have it to read this), it should work. If you can, get the version with the 4-port switch - it is fast and replaces the need for hub/switch. This device has a basic functionality of a router without expansive gear and complicated setup. Those of you who had a chance to program a real router know what I am talking about . If you do not feel comfortable setting up filters and ports, do not use the advanced setup. If you want to learn, read about it on Internet and try. This is a great networking tool. It is very easy to use - you don't even need to know what the router is.
My advice is, download the newest firmware upgrade as soon as you feel comfortable with the device. The new version has some fixes. Ping and tracert now works correctly. The firewall is foolproof by default (make sure that the "Block WAN Request" is enabled in Advanced setup). Before getting Linksys Router, I was using a free ZoneAlarm firewall, which worked well on the stand-alone computer. It always came up "Stealthy" on Gibson Research "Port Probe". Right out of the box, Linksys Router did not come "Stealthy", but showed the ports closed. I guess "Block WAN Request" was not enabled. I would not like any hacker who is scanning addresses for fast Cable/DSL starting in the 24. range, to know that I have any ports. The update takes care of this and it seems to speed up downloading.
I've hooked this router up so that two of my home computers can share a cable modem connection, and I was more than pleased with the connection rates. I didn't lose any of the upload/download bandwidth, and I can download from both computers simultaneously at the maximum download rate. Definitely a plus.
Many other reviewers are complaining of frequent lock-ups with the router, but I haven't had such an experience. One of my Win2000 computers has started to freeze considerably at boot-up after connecting with the router, but the other one still works fine so I can't say for sure if the router is the culprit.
The added firewall feature is the greatest perk, I think. I've been using ZoneAlarm Pro before and after installing this router and ever since, I have not received a single hacker alert (I was getting frequent alerts before). I still keep ZoneAlarm on, but I think the router is holding up its end very nicely.
As a final note, a couple of caveats. One, no ethernet cables are included, which was disappointing. You'll have to go out and buy your own. Secondly, the router itself doesn't look as great as the picture on the box. One you see it for yourself, you'll know what I mean. It's extremely light and seemingly made of cheap plastic. Not that it's flimsy, but I definitely wouldn't want to drop it even once. But the price is a steal. Compared to buying a second IP address and getting a retail fireall software package, this router definitely is the better deal.
Given the relatively low price, the lessened hassle for connecting multiple computers is wonderful, though I primarily purchased the BEFSR41 for the increased firewall security, which has been enough of a benefit in and of itself to more than justify the investment. On the potential downside, I've simply heard elsewhere of people being moderately confused if they desire to adjust security settings for internet gaming, video conferencing, etc. (though I know this is possible). Admittedly, I also haven't experimented yet with transfers between computers and whether or not using the Linksys for such is much of a hassle.
One of the most worthwhile investments I can recall having made in recent years, I give the BEFSR41 from Linksys a full and thorough recommendation. Only potential lingering doubts have to do with whether or not I should have purchased a model with wireless capability for potential future expansion, but I don't think I could be happier for my current ongoing needs/wants. Outstanding product, and Amazon had the best price(s) I could find. If you don't mind internet searching for how to handle more advanced uses you might have (like the gaming and file transfers between computers), I think you'll find this one of the best tech investments you can come across. Kudos to Amazon, too, for such a great price and immediate shipping.